|
Topics
Introduction
Problems Freedom Value Knowledge Life Mind Chance Quantum Entanglement Scandals Philosophers Mortimer Adler Rogers Albritton Alexander of Aphrodisias Samuel Alexander William Alston Anaximander G. E. M. Anscombe Anselm Louise Antony Thomas Aquinas Aristotle David Armstrong Harald Atmanspacher Robert Audi Augustine J. L. Austin A. J. Ayer Alexander Bain Mark Balaguer Jeffrey Barrett William Barrett William Belsham Henri Bergson George Berkeley Isaiah Berlin Richard J. Bernstein Bernard Berofsky Robert Bishop Max Black Susan Blackmore Susanne Bobzien Emil du Bois-Reymond Hilary Bok Laurence BonJour George Boole Émile Boutroux Daniel Boyd F. H. Bradley C. D. Broad Michael Burke Jeremy Butterfield Lawrence Cahoone C. A. Campbell Joseph Keim Campbell Rudolf Carnap Carneades Nancy Cartwright Gregg Caruso Ernst Cassirer David Chalmers Roderick Chisholm Chrysippus Cicero Tom Clark Randolph Clarke Samuel Clarke Anthony Collins August Compte Antonella Corradini Diodorus Cronus Jonathan Dancy Donald Davidson Mario De Caro Democritus William Dembski Brendan Dempsey Daniel Dennett Jacques Derrida René Descartes John Dewey Richard Double Fred Dretske Curt Ducasse John Earman Laura Waddell Ekstrom Epictetus Epicurus Austin Farrer Herbert Feigl Arthur Fine John Martin Fischer Kuno Fischer Frederic Fitch Owen Flanagan Luciano Floridi Philippa Foot Alfred Fouilleé Harry Frankfurt Richard L. Franklin Bas van Fraassen Michael Frede Gottlob Frege Peter Geach Edmund Gettier Carl Ginet Alvin Goldman Gorgias Nicholas St. John Green Niels Henrik Gregersen H. Paul Grice Ian Hacking Ishtiyaque Haji Stuart Hampshire W. F. R. Hardie Sam Harris William Hasker R. M. Hare Georg W. F. Hegel Martin Heidegger Heraclitus R. E. Hobart Thomas Hobbes David Hodgson Shadsworth Hodgson Baron d'Holbach Ted Honderich Pamela Huby David Hume Ferenc Huoranszki Frank Jackson William James Jon Jarrett Lord Kames Robert Kane Immanuel Kant Tomis Kapitan Walter Kaufmann Jaegwon Kim William King Hilary Kornblith Christine Korsgaard Saul Kripke Thomas Kuhn Andrea Lavazza James Ladyman Christoph Lehner Keith Lehrer Gottfried Leibniz Jules Lequyer Leucippus Michael Levin Joseph Levine George Henry Lewes C.I.Lewis David Lewis Peter Lipton C. Lloyd Morgan John Locke Michael Lockwood Arthur O. Lovejoy E. Jonathan Lowe John R. Lucas Lucretius Alasdair MacIntyre Ruth Barcan Marcus Tim Maudlin James Martineau Nicholas Maxwell Storrs McCall Hugh McCann Colin McGinn Michael McKenna Brian McLaughlin John McTaggart Paul E. Meehl Uwe Meixner Alfred Mele Trenton Merricks John Stuart Mill Dickinson Miller G. E. Moore Ernest Nagel Thomas Nagel Otto Neurath Friedrich Nietzsche John Norton P. H. Nowell-Smith Robert Nozick William of Ockham Timothy O'Connor Parmenides David F. Pears Charles Sanders Peirce Derk Pereboom Gualtiero Piccinini Steven Pinker U. T. Place Plato Karl Popper Porphyry Huw Price H. A. Prichard Protagoras Hilary Putnam Willard van Orman Quine Frank Ramsey Ayn Rand Michael Rea Thomas Reid Charles Renouvier Nicholas Rescher C. W. Rietdijk Richard Rorty Josiah Royce Bertrand Russell Paul Russell Gilbert Ryle Jean-Paul Sartre Kenneth Sayre T. M. Scanlon Moritz Schlick John Duns Scotus Albert Schweitzer Arthur Schopenhauer John Searle Wilfrid Sellars David Shiang Alan Sidelle Ted Sider Henry Sidgwick Walter Sinnott-Armstrong Peter Slezak J. J. C. Smart Saul Smilansky Michael Smith Baruch Spinoza Allen Stairs L. Susan Stebbing Isabelle Stengers George F. Stout Galen Strawson Peter Strawson Eleonore Stump Francisco Suárez Richard Taylor Kevin Timpe Mark Twain Peter Unger Peter van Inwagen Manuel Vargas John Venn Kadri Vihvelin Voltaire G. H. von Wright David Foster Wallace R. Jay Wallace W.G.Ward Ted Warfield Roy Weatherford C. F. von Weizsäcker William Whewell Alfred North Whitehead David Widerker David Wiggins Bernard Williams Timothy Williamson Ludwig Wittgenstein Susan Wolf Xenophon Scientists Emily Adlam David Albert Philip W. Anderson Michael Arbib Bobby Azarian Walter Baade Bernard Baars Jeffrey Bada Guido Bacciagaluppi Leslie Ballentine Marcello Barbieri Jacob Barandes Julian Barbour Horace Barlow Gregory Bateson Jakob Bekenstein John S. Bell Mara Beller Charles Bennett Ludwig von Bertalanffy Susan Blackmore Margaret Boden David Bohm Niels Bohr Ludwig Boltzmann John Tyler Bonner Emile Borel Max Born Satyendra Nath Bose Walther Bothe Jean Bricmont Hans Briegel Leon Brillouin Daniel Brooks Stephen Brush Henry Thomas Buckle S. H. Burbury Melvin Calvin William Calvin Donald Campbell John O. Campbell Sadi Carnot Sean B. Carroll Anthony Cashmore Eric Cavalcanti Eric Chaisson Gregory Chaitin Jean-Pierre Changeux Rudolf Clausius Arthur Holly Compton John Conway Simon Conway-Morris Peter Corning George Cowan Jerry Coyne John Cramer Francis Crick E. P. Culverwell Antonio Damasio Olivier Darrigol Charles Darwin Paul Davies Richard Dawkins Terrence Deacon Lüder Deecke Richard Dedekind Louis de Broglie Stanislas Dehaene Max Delbrück Abraham de Moivre David Depew Bernard d'Espagnat Paul Dirac Theodosius Dobzhansky Hans Driesch John Dupré John Eccles Arthur Stanley Eddington Gerald Edelman Paul Ehrenfest Manfred Eigen Albert Einstein George F. R. Ellis Walter Elsasser Hugh Everett, III Franz Exner Richard Feynman R. A. Fisher David Foster Joseph Fourier George Fox Philipp Frank Steven Frautschi Edward Fredkin Augustin-Jean Fresnel Karl Friston Benjamin Gal-Or Howard Gardner Lila Gatlin Michael Gazzaniga Nicholas Georgescu-Roegen GianCarlo Ghirardi J. Willard Gibbs James J. Gibson Nicolas Gisin Paul Glimcher Thomas Gold A. O. Gomes Brian Goodwin Julian Gough Joshua Greene Dirk ter Haar Jacques Hadamard Mark Hadley Ernst Haeckel Patrick Haggard J. B. S. Haldane Stuart Hameroff Augustin Hamon Sam Harris Ralph Hartley Hyman Hartman Jeff Hawkins John-Dylan Haynes Donald Hebb Martin Heisenberg Werner Heisenberg Hermann von Helmholtz Grete Hermann John Herschel Francis Heylighen Basil Hiley Art Hobson Jesper Hoffmeyer John Holland Don Howard John H. Jackson Ray Jackendoff Roman Jakobson Jon Jarrett E. T. Jaynes William Stanley Jevons Pascual Jordan Eric Kandel Ruth E. Kastner Stuart Kauffman Martin J. Klein William R. Klemm Christof Koch Simon Kochen Hans Kornhuber Stephen Kosslyn Daniel Koshland Ladislav Kovàč Leopold Kronecker Bernd-Olaf Küppers Rolf Landauer Alfred Landé Pierre-Simon Laplace Karl Lashley David Layzer Joseph LeDoux Jerome Lettvin Michael Levin Gilbert Lewis Benjamin Libet David Lindley Bruce Lindsay Grace Lindsay Seth Lloyd Werner Loewenstein Hendrik Lorentz Josef Loschmidt Alfred Lotka Ernst Mach Donald MacKay Henry Margenau Lynn Margulis Owen Maroney David Marr Lluis Masanes Humberto Maturana James Clerk Maxwell John Maynard Smith Ernst Mayr John McCarthy Barbara McClintock Warren McCulloch N. David Mermin George Miller Stanley Miller Ulrich Mohrhoff Jacques Monod Vernon Mountcastle Harold Morowitz Gerd B. Müller Markus P. Müller Emmy Noether Denis Noble Donald Norman Travis Norsen Howard T. Odum Alexander Oparin Abraham Pais Howard Pattee Wolfgang Pauli Massimo Pauri Wilder Penfield Roger Penrose Gualtiero Piccinini Steven Pinker Colin Pittendrigh Walter Pitts Max Planck Susan Pockett Henri Poincaré Michael Polanyi Daniel Pollen Ilya Prigogine Hans Primas Giulio Prisco Zenon Pylyshyn Henry Quastler Adolphe Quételet Pasco Rakic Nicolas Rashevsky Lord Rayleigh Frederick Reif Jürgen Renn Giacomo Rizzolati A.A. Roback Emil Roduner Juan Roederer Robert Rosen Frank Rosenblatt Jerome Rothstein David Ruelle David Rumelhart Michael Ruse Stanley Salthe Robert Sapolsky Tilman Sauer Ferdinand de Saussure Jürgen Schmidhuber Erwin Schrödinger Aaron Schurger Sebastian Seung Thomas Sebeok Franco Selleri Claude Shannon James A. Shapiro Charles Sherrington Abner Shimony Herbert Simon Dean Keith Simonton Edmund Sinnott B. F. Skinner Lee Smolin Ray Solomonoff Herbert Spencer Roger Sperry John Stachel Kenneth Stanley Henry Stapp Ian Stewart Tom Stonier Antoine Suarez Leonard Susskind Leo Szilard Max Tegmark Teilhard de Chardin Libb Thims William Thomson (Kelvin) Richard Tolman Giulio Tononi Peter Tse Alan Turing Robert Ulanowicz C. S. Unnikrishnan Nico van Kampen Antony Valentini Francisco Varela Vlatko Vedral Vladimir Vernadsky Clément Vidal Mikhail Volkenstein Heinz von Foerster Richard von Mises John von Neumann Jakob von Uexküll C. H. Waddington Sara Imari Walker James D. Watson John B. Watson Daniel Wegner Steven Weinberg August Weismann Paul A. Weiss Herman Weyl John Wheeler Jeffrey Wicken Wilhelm Wien Norbert Wiener Eugene Wigner E. O. Wiley E. O. Wilson Günther Witzany Carl Woese Stephen Wolfram H. Dieter Zeh Semir Zeki Ernst Zermelo Wojciech Zurek Konrad Zuse Fritz Zwicky Presentations ABCD Harvard (ppt) Bhaktivedanta Institute Biosemiotics Free Will Mental Causation James Symposium CCS25 Talk Evo Devo September 12 Evo Devo October 2 Evo Devo Davies Nov12 Is Man A Machine? |
Beyond Darwinism?
Beyond Darwinism describes efforts to go beyond the Modern Synthesis or "Neo-Darwinian" evolution developed in the early twentieth century by Julian Huxley, Theodosius Dobzhansky, Ernst Mayr, and others.
They include Evolutionary Development Biology or "Evo-Devo" theory, the Extended Evolutionary Synthesis, the Third Way of Evolution (TWE) project, and Evolution 2.0
Evolutionary Developmental Biology or "Evo-Devo"
Evolutionary developmental biology, informally known as evo-devo, grew from 19th-century beginnings, where embryology faced a mystery: zoologists did not know how embryonic development was controlled at the molecular level. Charles Darwin noted that having similar embryos implied common ancestry, but little progress was made until the 1970s. Then, recombinant DNA technology at last brought embryology together with molecular genetics.
One is deep homology, the finding that dissimilar organs such as the eyes of insects, vertebrates and cephalopod molluscs, long thought to have evolved separately, are controlled by similar genes such as pax-6, from the evo-devo gene toolkit. Still another possibility is the neo-Lamarckian theory that epigenetic changes are being inherited along with changes in DNA.
In 1977, a revolution in thinking about evolution and developmental biology began, with the arrival of recombinant DNA technology in genetics, the book Ontogeny and Phylogeny by Stephen J. Gould and the paper "Evolution and Tinkering"[28] by François Jacob. Gould laid to rest Haeckel's interpretation of evolutionary embryology, while Jacob set out an alternative theory. This led to a second synthesis, at last including embryology as well as molecular genetics, phylogeny, and evolutionary biology to form evo-devo.
In 1978, Edward B. Lewis discovered homeotic (homeobox, HOX) genes that regulate embryonic development in Drosophila fruit flies, which like all insects are arthropods, one of the major phyla of invertebrate animals. There were evidently strong similarities in the genes that controlled development across all the eukaryotes.
In 2001, a seminar entitled "From Embryology to Evo-Devo" (Evolutionary Biology) was held at the Marine Biology Laboratory at Woods Hole MA.
This Evo-Devo theory should not be confused with the Evo Devo Universe community.
Extended Evolutionary Synthesis
The Extended Evolutionary Synthesis (EES) augments the Modern Synthesis with additional causative factors. It includes multilevel selection, transgenerational epigenetic inheritance, niche construction, evolvability, and several concepts from evolutionary developmental biology
EES consists of a set of theoretical concepts argued to be more comprehensive than the earlier modern synthesis of evolutionary biology that took place between 1918 and 1942. The extended evolutionary synthesis was called for in the 1950s by C. H. Waddington, argued for on the basis of punctuated equilibrium by Stephen Jay Gould and Niles Eldredge in the 1980s.
EES was reconceptualized in 2007 by Gerd Müller and Massimo Pigliucci and their 2010 book Evolution: The Extended Synthesis, which is the current basis for work on the extended synthesis.
See the 2017 Royal Society article "Why an extended evolutionary synthesis is necessary" for further details.
The Third Way of Evolution
Denis Noble and James A. Shapiro established The Third Way of Evolution (TWE) project in 2014. The TWE, which is also known as the "Integrated Synthesis," shares many similarities with the extended evolutionary synthesis but is more radical in its claims. The TWE consists of a group of researchers who provide a "Third Way" alternative to creationism and the modern synthesis. The TWE predicts that the modern synthesis will be replaced with an entirely new evolutionary framework. Similar to the extended evolutionary synthesis (EES), advocates cite examples of developmental bias, genetic assimilation, niche construction, non-genetic inheritance, phenotypic plasticity and other evolutionary processes. Shapiro's natural genetic engineering, a process described to account for novelty created in biological evolution is also important for the TWE.
The difference between the extended synthesis and the TWE is that TWE calls for an entire replacement of the modern synthesis rather than an extension.
Noble has proposed Ten Principles of Systems Biology:[
Biological functionality is multi-level
Transmission of information is not one way
DNA is not the sole transmitter of inheritance
The theory of biological relativity: there is no privileged level of causality
Gene ontology will fail without higher-level insight
There is no genetic program
There are no programs at any other level
There are no programs in the brain
The self is not an object
There are many more to be discovered; a genuine 'theory of biology' does not yet exist
Venn diagram of the Integrated Synthesis of TWE
James A. Shapiro has discovered
regulatory networks that adapt to stress conditions to maximize the probability of survival.
All living cells sense and respond to changes in external or internal conditions. Without that cognitive capacity, they could not obtain nutrition essential for growth, survive inevitable ecological changes, or correct accidents in the complex processes of reproduction. Wherever examined, even the smallest living cells (prokaryotes) display sophisticated regulatory networks establishing appropriate adaptations to stress conditions that maximize the probability of survival. Supposedly “simple” prokaryotic organisms also display remarkable capabilities for intercellular signalling and multicellular coordination. These observations indicate that all living cells are cognitive.Shapiro explicitly explains that this cognitive behavior is "purposeful"... Rather than being the passive beneficiaries of random mutations and natural selection, all organisms play an active role in their hereditary variation and natural selection by activating transposable elements in response to ecological challenges.These "purposeful" internal regulatory networks may be invisible, but they complement the clearly visible and purposeful behaviors of the simplest prokaryotes like bacteria rotating their flagella counterclockwise when measurement along their cell surface signals better conditions ahead, but who rotate clockwise and tumble, then start off in a random direction in search of better conditions.
Evolution 2.0
Denis Noble is also a major participant in an ambitious program called Evolution 2.0. Noble, Harvard geneticist George Church and advertising strategist Perry Marshall, are offering an incentive prize ten times the size of the Nobel – believed to be the largest single award ever in basic science – to the person or team solving the largest mystery in history: how genetic code inside cells got there, and how cells intentionally self-organize, communicate, then purposely adapt. This $10 million challenge, the Evolution 2.0 Prize can be found at herox.com/evolution2.0.
Do Efforts to Get Beyond the Modern Synthesis (Variation in DNA) Really Get Beyond Darwinism?
Evolutionary Developmental Biology or "Evo-Devo," the Extended Evolutionary Synthesis (EES), and the Third Way of Evolution (TWE) have all added new sources of variation in what gets inherited in the next generation.
But there is no change in Darwin's fundamental idea of natural selection, popularly known as "Survival of the Fittest." Indeed, Darwin knew nothing of DNA and the Genetic Code.
Many thinkers who want to get Beyond Darwinism seem to oppose the random (chance) source of variation and are looking to find purpose in the universe, even before the origin of life. This purpose would determine the creation of new species, including humans.
The Evo Devo Universe
What is Evo-Devo?
Evo-devo is a subfield of genetics, applied and theoretical biology, complexity science, and philosophy, first emerging in the 1990s, that explores how cyclic developmental processes direct, regulate, and constrain evolutionary change in autopoietic (self-maintaining, self-replicating, and creative) complex adaptive systems. Perhaps no one explains evo-devo genetics and dynamics better and faster than in this fun 4-minute music video, Evo-Devo, by Tim Blais of A Capella Science.
To best understand ontology (the nature of life), this field might be best called "devo-evo", considering developmental self-maintenance, self-replication, sequential hierarchy, and modularity first in any theory of life's complexity, and evolutionary variation as logically secondary, as no inheritance can be perfect in an entropic universe, and as variation must be constrained by the minimal viability needs of a developmental life cycle. Leading scholars in evo-devo biology, including Brian K. Hall and Gunther Wagner, argued as much in 2000. But inertia had grown by then, and we are stuck with the name that emerged at the field's birth circa 1990.
The short pitch for why development is more fundamental and miraculous than evolutionary variation is that it reliably created each of us, from a seed we cannot even see. It is the reason our children look and act so much like us, and we like each other. The robust hierarchical complexity that emerges from the highly-tuned initial conditions and parameters of that seed includes our conscious brain, our anatomy and physiology, our immune system, and the ethics and personality traits stabilizing our societies.
Normal | Teacher | Scholar
|