John Dupré
(1952-)
John A. Dupré is a British philosopher of science who directs
Egenis, the Centre for the Study of Life Sciences at the University of Exeter, where he is also a professor of philosophy. Dupré is a member of the "Stanford School" of philosophy of science, along with
Nancy Cartwright,
Ian Hacking,
Patrick Suppes and
Peter Galison.
In 2012, he offered the book
Processes of Life: Essays in the Philosophy of Biology
In 2018, with his Exeter colleague D.J. Nicholson, he published
Everything Flows: Towards a Processual Philosophy of Biology
In 2022, he delivered the Gifford Lectures on
A Brief History of Form at the University of Aberdeen,[4] and again in 2023 at the University of Edinburgh on
A Process Perspective on Human Life.
Dupré's "process perspective" argues
"that it is a mistake to suppose that processes require underlying things, or substances... Instead of thinking of processes as belonging to things, we should think of things as being derived from processes. This does not mean that things do not exist, even less that thing-concepts cannot be extremely useful or illuminating. What it does imply is that things cannot be regarded as the basic building blocks of reality. What we identify as things are no more than transient patterns of stability in the surrounding flux, temporary eddies in the continuous flow of process."
Everything Flows, p.12
Dupré identifies an essential difference between the familiar atoms and molecules of physics and chemistry and the organic macromolecules of biology. Information philosophy understands that difference as
the role played by information in the processes that
create new purely physical things and new living biological entireties. Physical processes are
reductive and eliminative materialist. Biological processes are
emergent and
These are the very special anti-entropic processes information philosophy calls
ergodic (information creating).
The first information structures formed in the early universe, elementary particles, atoms and molecules, galaxies, stars, and planets, are all the result of microscopic quantum cooperative phenomena and macroscopic gravitational forces. These things are not acting. They are acted upon by forces of Nature
But it is not until the emergence of life that information replication, information communication, and information processing begins. Only then is information itself used in the creation of new - living - information structures. Living things are biological information processors, forms through which matter and energy flows, with capabilities far beyond the electronic digital computers that cognitive scientists think provide a “computational theory of mind.”
Most important, living things have “purposes.” They engage in communications of information with other living things and with their environment. Their messaging is
meaningful, allowing them to be
active users of information - which makes them
agents, compared to passive material things, whose structural information is largely inert and meaningless in itself.
Since the total of matter and energy in the universe is a conserved constant, it's the
arrangement of the matter and energy that is the information. Information philosophy (and science) tells us
who or
what is doing the arranging. In physics and chemistry, the forces in processes creating more complex objects are purely
passive. In all of biology the
active forces creating more complex organisms deploy information templates (e.g., the "central dogma" of DNA to mRNA to proteins). At animal and human levels these active creative processes become intentional, "mind over matter."
As Dupré's colleague
Anne Sophie Meincke stressed in a recent conference, living things are "agents." They introduce
purpose into the universe.
We should note that where Dupré argues that "things cannot be regarded as the basic building blocks of reality," philosopher
Trenton Merricks argues the exact opposite, defending "mereological nihilism, the idea that there are no composite objects, only "simples" arranged to look like objects. Or as
Peter van Inwagen said in his 1990 book
Material Beings, There are "no tables, only simples arranged tablewise."
Normal |
Teacher |
Scholar