Hidden Variables
David Bohm in 1951 and 1952 proposed "hidden variables" as a way to explain the
apparent "
nonlocality" of simultaneous measurements of the
entangled spins of electrons that are separated at a great distance. The hidden variables provide the information needed at the distant “entangled” particle, so it can coordinate its properties perfectly with the “local” particle.
The hidden variables are thought to be "local," traveling with the particles to exert an "influence" on the particles that can explain their perfect correlations.
Bohm wrote in 1952,
The usual interpretation of the quantum theory is
based on an assumption having very far-reaching
implications, ~i.e., that the physical state of an individual
system is completely specified by a wave
function that determines only the probabilities of actual
results that can be obtained in a statistical ensemble of
similar experiments. This assumption has been the
object of severe criticisms, notably on the part of
Einstein, who has always believed that, even at the
quantum level, there must exist precisely definable
elements or dynamical variables determining (as in
classical physics) the actual behavior of each individual
system, and not merely its probable behavior. Since
these elements or variables are not now included in the
quantum theory and have not yet been detected experimentally,
Einstein has always regarded the present
form of the quantum theory as incomplete, although he
admits its internal consistency.
"A Suggested Interpretation of the Quantum Theory in Terms of ‘Hidden’ Variables. I,” Physical Review, vol.85, no.2. p.166, 1952
Because 1) the measurements are simultaneous, because 2) the particles are in a "space-like" separation, because 3) the spins are randomly up or down according to the
uncertainty principle of quantum mechanics, and because 4) measurement of each particle changes the electron spin direction to be aligned with the Stern-Gerlach measuring device, it is mistakenly thought that measurements would result in outcomes that are randomly + -, - +, + +, and - -.
Some mechanism is thought to be needed to ensure that only perfectly opposite spins of + - and - + are observed. Since the particles are in a space-like separation, any "action-at-a-distance" to ensure their spins are opposite would have to be faster than the speed of light, so impossible.
John Bell in 1964 developed a
theorem and proposed an experiment that he said could distinguish between the predictions of "local hidden variables" and standard quantum mechanics.
In the years since, hundreds of such experiments have proved that no such "local hidden variables" exist.
We propose that just before their simultaneous measurements, the two-particle wave function describing the particles has no
preferred direction of spins and total spin angular momentum zero, conserving total spin from the spherically symmetric wave function at initial entanglement.
We call this constant spin zero a "
hidden constant of the motion." It is not a "hidden
variable" that must act at a distance, but a "hidden
constant," the jointly shared property of the two particles, true from their initial state preparation, that provides the conditions needed to measure their spins as + - and - +, provided the two measuring devices are perfectly aligned (by prior agreement).
References
Belinfante, F. J. (1973)
A Survey of Hidden-Variable Theories, Pergamon Press.
Bohm, D. (1951)
Quantum Theory. Prentice-Hall.
Bohm, D. (1952)
A Suggested Interpretation of the Quantum Theory in Terms of "Hidden" Variables. I
______,
A Suggested Interpretation of the Quantum Theory in Terms of "Hidden" Variables. II
Bohm, D. and Y. Aharononov (1957)
Discussion of Experimental Proof for the Paradox of Einstein, Rosen, and Podolsky
Einstein A., B.Podolsky, and N. Rosen (1935) "
Can Quantum-mechanical Description of Physical Reality Be Considered Complete?,"
Quantum Theory and Measurement, Ed. Wheeler and Zurek, p.138,
Physical Review, 47, 777-80 (
PDF)
For Teachers
To hide this material, click on the Normal link.
For Scholars
To hide this material, click on the Teacher or Normal link.
Normal |
Teacher |
Scholar